You roll over in bed, or tip your head back to reach a top shelf at Publix, and the room takes off spinning. It stops after a few seconds. Then it happens again the next morning. If that sounds familiar, this week’s Pain 2 Power guest has spent most of his career on exactly that problem. Dr. John Li is an ear, nose and throat specialist in Jupiter, and he joined Dave Kashuba and Mike McGann to explain vertigo in plain English, with the best analogies we have heard on the show.
His description of the inner ear is the one people will remember. “You have nerves embedded in jello and then to make that jello move more, you put some rocks on top of it,” Dr. Li said. Those rocks, and what happens when a few of them wander off, are most of the story.
By The First Rehabilitation Team · Reviewed by Dr. Dave Kashuba, Ph.D.
An ENT from Jupiter who builds flight simulators
Dave and Dr. Li met in their late twenties and celebrated their 30th birthdays together. Both are in their sixties now. Dave calls him a buddy, and also the doctor a large share of his dizzy patients have already been told to see. Dr. Li practices with ENT and Allergy Associates of Florida in Jupiter, and his office number, as he gave it on air, is 561-748-4445.
Before the medicine, though, Mike wanted the backstory. He got a good one.
From Taiwan with zero English
Dave asked how much English he knew when he came to America. “Zero,” Dr. Li said. He came from Taiwan. Mike, who admits he chases shiny objects on this show, then pulled the conversation toward the side of Dr. Li’s life most guests don’t have.
Pencil sketches in anatomy class
In medical school, anatomy meant learning every structure in cross section, and this was before anyone could snap a photo with a phone. Not everybody made it to class on time. So Dr. Li pencil sketched the sections, labeled them, and shared them with his group so they could learn the structures. Some of the drawings ended up in textbooks. “It was good McDonald’s money,” he said. He also illustrated medical brochures and a couple of books.
Then came the airplanes. He has loved flying since he was a kid sitting in the refrigerator box making engine noises. He started building his own simulators, and it grew into a company building flight simulators for F-15s, F-16s, F-22s and F-35s. One day Marvel called. They needed flight grips and ejection seats for an F-15 scene in Captain Marvel. Later Paramount called without saying what the parts were for. It turned out to be Top Gun. “Whatever they’re holding, that’s us,” he said of the controls in the back seat.
How a Channel 5 story spread the Epley maneuver
Years ago almost nobody had heard of the Epley maneuver or the crystals behind it. Dr. Li described himself back then as a “nobody doc here in Jupiter, Florida” who went to a conference and met Dr. John Epley, the doctor who came up with the procedure. They became good friends, and Dr. Epley taught him how to do it.
His first reaction was honest. “This sounds kind of hokey, but may as well try it, what the heck,” he remembered thinking. He brought it home to West Palm Beach and Jupiter. One of his early patients turned out to be a news reporter at Channel 5. She came back to interview him, the story went out across the country, and calls came in from all over. His cousin in the Seattle area phoned to ask why his face was on her TV. It went viral, in other words, before anybody called it that.
Nerves in jello, rocks on top: how your inner ear senses motion
To understand vertigo, Dr. Li said, start with what the inner ear is built to do. It is full of motion detectors, and they come in two kinds.
Moving forward, back, up and down
Two small structures, the utricle and the saccule, sense straight line motion: forward and back, side to side, up and down. That is where the jello and the rocks come in. When you hit the gas, the rocks lag a little and pull the jello back, and your brain reads that as acceleration. When the jello catches up, you are at a steady speed and the feeling fades. Nobody in the studio had heard it put that way before, and Dave pointed out that it fits the physics of inertia.
Turning and spinning
Rotation is handled separately, by three semicircular canals. Dr. Li compared them to three tires set in three different planes, the way an airplane can pitch up and down, roll, and yaw side to side on its rudder. Straight line motion and spinning motion are kept apart. That separation is what goes wrong in the most common kind of vertigo.
What benign positional vertigo actually is
Say you take a knock to the head. Some of the tiny rocks on the gel can break loose and settle in a small cup, and that cup connects to the semicircular canals. A few of them end up in the wrong place. “So benign positional vertigo is rocks that are out of place,” Dr. Li said. The medical name for them is otoliths. He calls them ear rocks, and some people call them crystals.
Once they are inside the spinning sensors, ordinary head movements set them off. “Imagine you got a tire, you throw some pebbles in it, you roll the tire, the pebbles go clunk, clunk, clunk,” he said. That pulls on a nerve, and you feel dizzy. A lot of people just live with it, mostly by avoiding looking up.
The roofer who sat down on the roof
Dave told the story of a patient from about 25 years ago who owned a roofing company. One day on a roof he got so dizzy that he kept falling to one side while he watched the edge come closer, so he sat down. Everything kept spinning. Later it happened again when he looked up at the shelves in Publix. Dave recognized what it was, told him he had the guy for him, and sent him to Dr. Li. He went back to roofing. Mike’s takeaway was that he now knows who to call for a roof.
Tip the tire, dump the pebbles
The good news about this one is that it is treatable. If you have pebbles in a tire, Dr. Li explained, you rotate the tire, and there is an opening where the pebbles can drop back into the cup where they belong. That is what the Epley maneuver and the other repositioning moves do. The hosts joked that somebody should build a chair that spins you around to do it. Dr. Li already has one. His office calls it the multi axial positioning device, and it can turn a person completely upside down. He was clear that other kinds of vertigo are harder to treat than this one.
Dizzy or vertigo? What the words mean
Dave asked the question a lot of listeners have: if that is benign positional vertigo, then what is vertigo, and what is plain dizziness? Dr. Li drew the lines like this. Dizziness is the broad word for not feeling right, and it covers a spinning feeling, a lightheaded feeling, or a feeling like you might black out. Vertigo is narrower. “You’re talking about a sense of motion, a feeling of motion when there isn’t motion,” he said. Because the horizontal canal is the one you feel most, vertigo usually feels like spinning like a top.
| Term | What he said it means | Where it starts |
|---|---|---|
| Dizziness | The broad category: not feeling right, whether spinning, lightheaded or close to blacking out | Many possible causes |
| Vertigo | A feeling of motion when there isn’t motion, usually spinning | Most often the semicircular canals |
| Benign positional vertigo | A smaller subset of vertigo: ear rocks in the wrong canal, set off by head position | Inner ear |
| Meniere’s | Another type of vertigo, which he called neuro-otologic | Inner ear |
| Vestibular migraine | Vertigo that comes from migraine, which he called a big thing now | Brain |
Meniere’s and vestibular migraine
Asked whether Meniere’s is neurological, Dr. Li said no: it happens at the level of the inner ear, so he would call it neuro-otologic. Vestibular migraine is the one that lives at the brain level. It came up on air that a lot of people aren’t sure how some of these conditions should be treated, which is one more reason to get the right diagnosis first.
Where the neck comes in
Dave was careful about what therapy can and can’t do here. He can’t stop a migraine. What he looks for is tightness that can act as a trigger, in muscles like the sternocleidomastoid at the front of the neck and the levator scapula running down to the shoulder blade. Releasing that tightness, he said, can help calm things down without curing the migraine. Our page on headaches driven by the neck and the neck pain page go further into that side of it.
The seated exercises Dave walked through
Dave described a simple routine he gives people to settle things down at home. You sit in a chair for all of it. Here it is as he laid it out on air.
| Step | What you do | How many |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed gaze | Sit up straight and stare at something in front of you for 20 seconds | 6 times |
| Eyes only | Keep your head still and move your eyes side to side, then up and down | 6 times |
| Near and far | Look at your finger, then at something far away | 6 times |
| Head turns | Slowly turn your head to the right and to the left | 6 times |
| Head nods | Slowly move your head up and down | 6 times |
Dave’s point was modest. Done slowly, it can help calm the dizziness enough that you can stand again. A second set came up by name too, the Brandt Daroff exercises, which people do on their own couch or bed. Part of the reason is that the Epley procedure can leave some people a little sick to their stomach, so it pays to go slowly. If you have new dizziness, or you have never been told what is causing yours, start with your doctor rather than a routine you read online.
Two compasses: how therapy retrains the brain
Patients often tell Dave they feel like they’re walking like a drunk sailor, drifting to one side. Dr. Li explained why. If a virus weakens your right inner ear, you tend to lean toward the bad side, the way a car with a flat on the right pulls to the right.
Then he gave the analogy the hosts liked best. Your eyes are like video cameras and your ears are like microphones. Your inner ears, he said, are more like two compasses. When both point north, you feel fine. When one starts pointing a little east, your brain gets two answers, and with your eyes closed you wobble because it doesn’t know which one to believe. “What you’re trying to do is retrain the brain to read your compasses differently,” he said. He compared it to wearing a watch that runs 30 minutes fast. Once you know, you subtract the 30 minutes every time you look, and you’re back on time.
That, he said, is why therapy helps people with vestibular weakness and balance problems so much. Dave’s reaction was that he had never described it that way, but that it is what the practice does every day.
What this looks like if you call us
When someone comes to us listing to one side, the first job is figuring out why. It could be weakness. It could be something that belongs with an ENT first, and then we send you to the right doctor, Dr. Li included. Balance and fall prevention, vestibular work for dizziness and neurological rehab are all part of our physical therapy program. Your first visit is about an hour, one-on-one, and treatment usually starts that day. If falls are part of the worry, our guide to strength training after 60 and fall prevention covers the strength side.
Ten tickles, and where to find the episode
Every show ends with a joke, and this week Dave got his from a young listener. A few weeks after he showed a patient some exercises for her knee, there was a voicemail on his office phone from her little boy. He thanked Dr. Dave for helping his mom, said he had heard Dave likes dad jokes, and asked how many tickles it takes to make an octopus laugh. Ten tickles. Tentacles. Dave admitted he hit the wrong button trying to save the message.
Listen to the full conversation on the Pain 2 Power podcast page, watch it in our video library, or read more about Dr. John Li on his guest page. His office number, as he gave it on air, is 561-748-4445. The show airs live Saturdays at 8:30 AM on 100.3 Legends Radio.
We are a physical, occupational and hand therapy clinic on US-1 in North Palm Beach. If dizziness, a balance problem or a stiff neck is getting in the way of your day, call us at 561-624-4263 to book an evaluation. If what we find points to the inner ear, we will tell you, and we will tell you who to see.
This article is general information, not medical advice. Every situation is different, so please consult a qualified professional about yours.