Maybe it started with a heavy suitcase, a new pickleball paddle, or the way you hold your phone in bed. Now the outside of your elbow aches every time you lift a coffee cup, and it has for weeks. Or the pain is lower, at the base of your thumb, and opening a jar has turned into a two-handed job. On Episode 16 of Pain 2 Power, Dave Kashuba and Mike McGann sat down with the surgeon a lot of those people end up seeing: Dr. Matt Butler, MD, a hand and upper extremity orthopedic surgeon with HSS in West Palm Beach.
The hour covered three things most listeners have run into, or will. Tennis elbow and why most of it never needs an operation. The elbow injuries now turning up in young baseball pitchers. And a thumb joint replacement Dr. Butler started offering this year.
By The First Rehabilitation Team · Reviewed by Dr. Dave Kashuba, Ph.D.
A West Palm Beach hand surgeon who sends patients to physical therapy first
Dave introduced him as a local superstar who has been in the area for a little over three years and is making a name for himself. Dave also credited Dr. Ryan Simovitch, the shoulder surgeon from Episode 8, with bringing Dr. Butler into the circle. The two send patients back and forth, and that relationship shaped the whole conversation.
“I take care of people’s arms”
Asked what he does, Dr. Butler gave the formal title first, fellowship trained hand and upper extremity orthopedic surgeon, and then the plain version. “I take care of people’s arms,” he said. That runs from the fingertip to the shoulder, but mostly the elbow, wrist and hand: injuries, aches and pains, and arthritis.
He told Mike why he chose it. Orthopedic training rotates you through hips, knees, spines, shoulders and feet, and the hand stood out for its intricacy and for how much we rely on it. His patients come from everywhere, he said, from kids born with hand problems to older adults with worn joints, workers hurt on the job and artists with repetitive strain. Plenty of them tell him they really need their hands. “I say, well, everybody does,” he said.
Tennis elbow: why most cases never reach an operating room
Mike already knew the topic from the inside. Before the show, Dave had worked on Mike’s sore elbow for a few minutes in the clinic. “I’ve had zero pain since you did it,” Mike said on air. “I forgot that even happened.” Dave was quick to add that Mike’s was an easy one. Mike has his own theory about how it started: the way he holds his Kindle with one finger when he reads, which is a lot.
What is actually going on in the elbow
Dr. Butler stepped back to explain the condition, which doctors call lateral epicondylitis. He thinks of it as close to universal. At some point in middle age, he said, most people get a sore elbow. For the lucky ones it lasts a day or two. For others it hangs around. The tendon that anchors the forearm muscles to the bone starts to wear, the way any mechanical part does over time, and as it frays some people develop pain from it. The name fools people. Most of the patients who get it don’t play tennis.
Most cases settle down with rest and time, and Dr. Butler said he is often not the first person a patient sees for it. When he is, he usually sends them to Dave. “He’s got things that are going to fix 90% of them,” he said. That figure is his estimate from his own practice, not a promise for any one elbow, and every case is different.
What Dave does in the clinic
Dave walked through it. The old approach was deep cross friction massage, which hurt like the dickens. Here is what he described using instead:
- Active release technique, which puts dynamic pressure on the tissue while it moves, and is what he used on Mike
- Dynamic cupping with small cups, moved slowly across the sore area, sometimes with an actual sink plunger (yes, you will see one in the office)
- Blood flow restriction training, with a cuff on the upper arm during exercise, so that releasing it sends more blood back into the area
The cupping is the part people remember. Dave said the cup slows down as it passes over scar tissue, and little by little the area releases until the cup glides smoothly. That tells him the treatment is done. “It takes maybe 45 seconds, which seems like 45 minutes,” he said. Mike, who has had it, admitted it was not his favorite minute.
When surgery does make sense
For the smaller group whose elbow keeps hurting after a real course of therapy, Dr. Butler described how surgery has changed. The traditional operation, named after Dr. Nirschl, opens the elbow and cleans out the torn part of the tendon. “You take a tear and make it bigger, I guess,” he said, and surprisingly it tends to work. He has moved to something newer: after cleaning out the worn area, he adds a biologic patch, a collagen scaffold originally developed for the shoulder, to help the tendon heal. He said it has gone well for his patients so far, and that it does carry a recovery period.
Dave offered a candid aside. He has seen those patches used a lot in shoulders and doesn’t think the results there are fabulous, because the shoulder moves so much more. The elbow, as he put it, is a smaller zip code. Dr. Butler agreed that made sense.
Golfer’s elbow or a Tommy John injury? Telling them apart
The inside of the elbow is a different story. Medial epicondylitis, usually called golfer’s elbow, is the same kind of wear on the tendons that bend the wrist and fingers, the ones you feel when you shake hands. Dave did not sugarcoat it. Every therapist in the world hates to get that one, he said, because it is a hard one to fix.
For athletes, the bigger question is whether the pain is a tendon at all, or the ulnar collateral ligament (UCL), the ligament Tommy John surgery repairs. Dave described the hands-on tests he uses to sort them out, starting with pressing on the exact spot and then stressing the elbow in different positions. Dr. Butler added the milking maneuver, another exam test, and a special MRI developed at HSS called a stress view. The elbow is held under a sideways load during the scan, and if the joint gaps open, that points to a stretched or torn ligament. He said they have mostly moved away from using contrast dye for these scans because the newer magnets are good enough without it.
Mike wanted to know if you still have to slide all the way into the tube for an arm. You do. Dr. Butler said he asks the MRI techs about it all the time, and the images still need the arm in the middle of the machine.
Why young pitchers are showing up with elbow injuries
This was the part of the hour aimed at parents. Dr. Butler said medial elbow pain has become a real problem in youth baseball, and he pointed to two causes.
One sport, all year, thrown harder
The first is single sport participation. Kids used to rotate from football to basketball to soccer to baseball. Now many pick one sport at a young age and play it year round, so the same joint takes the same stress all year. The second is velocity. “Everyone is throwing smoke now, even in high school,” Dr. Butler said, and the elbow is seeing forces it never used to see.
Mike compared it to rotating crops on a farm, giving different parts of the body a rest while others work. Dr. Butler liked it. “100%, I think that’s a great analogy,” he said.
In younger kids, the result is often a stress fracture through the growth plate. He called it a hard problem to treat, because the pattern repeats: the child rests, feels better, goes back to playing, and the pain comes back.
The dropped shoulder
Dave coached kids through middle school for years, and he said parents would often want to get a sore pitcher right back in the game. What he looks for, often before the elbow ever hurts, is a dropped shoulder. In baseball and softball, when the shoulder drops, the arm angle changes and the throw starts leading with the elbow instead of driving through the legs. That puts the load on the inner elbow. In kids, Dave said, it tends to show up as a stress fracture or a strained ligament rather than a full tear, because young joints are pretty flexible.
Dr. Butler was honest about where his job ends. “I’m not a pitching coach, I don’t have a baseball background,” he said. His advice is to send young throwers to someone sport specific, like Dave, who can work on throwing mechanics alongside the rehab.
Basal thumb arthritis and a new thumb joint replacement
This was the reason Dave booked the show. Dr. Butler does a procedure, Dave said, that not a lot of doctors do.
The joint that makes a thumb a thumb
“It’s really an exciting time in the United States for treatment of something that is exceedingly common in the population,” Dr. Butler said. Almost all women develop arthritis in the joint at the base of the thumb, he explained, and many men do too. It is a saddle shaped joint, and it is what lets us move the thumb away from the fingers, the opposable thumb that sets us apart from other primates. Every pinch and every grip loads it, and over the years the cartilage wears.
Dave added that people often confuse it with other thumb and wrist problems, such as De Quervain’s, and that a good hand therapist can usually tell the difference early with the right testing.
The standard surgery, and what replaces it
The usual operation in the United States is still a trapeziectomy. The surgeon removes the trapezium, a small bone that makes up half of the joint, and usually fills the space with a tendon or graft. Dr. Butler said it works for people with debilitating pain. The recovery is the hard part: at least six weeks immobilized, sometimes eight, then months of rehab, and strength never fully comes back. “We know that the pinch strength never totally normalizes,” he said.
The alternative he now offers is an implant that replaces both sides of the joint, built much like a hip replacement with a dual mobility design. He said surgeons in Europe have used it for about 15 years, the dual mobility version has cut down on loosening of the cup, and it recently received FDA clearance. He started doing the procedure this year. “The results have been fantastic early on,” he said. That is his early experience, and whether it fits a given thumb is a conversation between a patient and their surgeon.
| Condition | What was said about it | What they described doing |
|---|---|---|
| Tennis elbow (lateral epicondylitis) | Wear and fraying of the tendon on the outside of the elbow, common in middle age, mostly in people who don’t play tennis | Therapy first; for stubborn cases, cleaning out the tendon, now with a collagen patch |
| Golfer’s elbow (medial epicondylitis) | The same kind of wear on the inside of the elbow, which Dave called hard to fix | Exam tests to rule out a ligament injury, then rest and therapy |
| UCL injury (the Tommy John ligament) | Can look like golfer’s elbow in a thrower | Exam tests such as the milking maneuver, and a stress view MRI developed at HSS |
| Growth plate stress fracture | Showing up in young pitchers who play one sport year round and throw hard | Rest, then mechanics and rehab, which Dr. Butler called hard because the cycle repeats |
| Basal thumb arthritis | Arthritis at the base of the thumb, which almost all women and many men develop | Hand therapy; trapeziectomy for severe cases; a newly FDA cleared joint replacement |
Where hand therapy fits, before and after surgery
Near the end, Mike made the point that it is awfully hard for a layman to tell one kind of arm pain from another. All we know, he said, is that the shoulder hurts, the elbow hurts, or the hand doesn’t work right. His advice: “Don’t just go onto Dr. Internet.” Dave pointed out the clinic offers free consultations, and that part of the job is knowing which doctor to send you to. For wrist problems, he said, that is Dr. Butler.
That two way street is how our hand therapy program works. Laura Drumm, MS, OTR/L, CHT, our certified hand therapist, treats from the fingertips to the elbow, and many thumb arthritis patients start with conservative care such as splinting before surgery comes up at all. Our hand and wrist page covers the conditions we see most, and why hand therapy is its own specialty explains what the CHT credential means. Common questions about getting started are in the hand therapy section of our FAQ. When a patient’s evaluation points to a surgical opinion, we say so and coordinate with their surgeon. When a patient comes to us after surgery, we work from the surgeon’s protocol.
A missing letter, and where to find the episode
Every show ends with a dad joke. This week a teacher keeps a fifth grader named Jeremy after school, because he only knows 25 of the 26 letters of the alphabet. She asks him why. He says he doesn’t know why.
Listen to the full conversation on the Pain 2 Power podcast page, watch it in our video library, or read more about Dr. Matt Butler on his guest page. His office number at HSS, as he gave it on air, is 561-657-4670. The show airs live Saturdays at 8:30 AM on 100.3 Legends Radio.
We are a physical, occupational and hand therapy clinic on US-1 in North Palm Beach. If an elbow, wrist or thumb is getting in the way of your day, call us at 561-624-4263 to book an evaluation. If what we find points to a surgeon, we will tell you, and we will tell you who to see.
This article is general information, not medical advice. Every situation is different, so please consult a qualified professional about yours.